NME.COM | uncut.co.uk
Uncut.co.uk - Music and Movies with something to say
Sign up to the Uncut Newsletter
Music InterviewsMusic ReviewsMusic Special Features
Related Links
Subscriber Benefits
The Beatles
As time recedes, how bizarrely indiscriminate the English invasion of the US seems to us now. Ringo was initially deemed the cutest Beatle and, for a while, America embraced The Dave Clark Five and Herman's Hermits as willingly as it shrieked at the Fab Four. This arbitrary Anglophilia endured well beyond the initial invasion. Never let it be forgotten that the Hermits' "'Enery The Eighth" and The New Vaudeville Band's "Winchester Cathedral" were both Billboard No 1s and spawned more novelty imitations than you can imagine. America couldn't get enough of our quaintness.

Dissenting voices were, of course, all but drowned out by the screams. Those aggrieved older heads who didn't want their Arthur Alexander and their "Roll Over Beethoven" re-interpreted for the mewling puking masses could like it or lump it. For nearly three years, until the seismic aftershock of Shea Stadium died down, that ubiquitous twang was the only show in town. Kiss goodbye to the golden age of girl groups. Wave ta-ta to surf-pop.

Thanks to eccentric licensing, America had an equally skewed encounter with the Fabs chronology. By the time Murray The K and co got to the party, The Beatles were already on their fourth UK hit. Previous US labels had let the cash cow slip from their grip like so much unpatented Epstein merchandise, so Capitol had to play a hasty game of catch-up with the release schedule. Thankfully, they took a less anally retentive approach to the inclusion of singles on albums than their British counterparts.

For current collectors and completists, however, the haphazard chronology is slightly more problematic. Meet The Beatles is basically Parlophone's With The Beatles plus singles, the remainder of With The Beatles finding its way onto the imaginatively titled The Beatles Second Album alongside selective B-sides (the classic "You Can't Do That" and "I'll Get You") and EP tracks. Something New, the most incongruous mish-mash of all, is the Hard Day's Night soundtrack with - duh? - the title track and "Can't Buy Me Love" replaced by the German version of "I Want To Hold Your Hand" and McCartney's lame take on Carl Perkins' "Matchbox". Beatles '65 lumps half of Beatles For Sale with whatever was left over.

Chronologically, then, they make little sense. As an aural document of what made teen America moist, however, the collection is pretty hard to beat. Lyrically, that combination of Merseypool punning and codified smut was lethal. The amphetamine gulp and the exuberant energy unleashed the emotions of a generation. The screamers understood. And as for the wider musical influence, well, the future Mamas & Papas would have still been playing Hootenanny if they hadn't heard "I Call Your Name", while The Byrds' blueprint can be heard in every Rickenbacker chime. Approximately 10,000 other high-school hoppers and garage punks to be taken into account, m'lud.
"Oh, I get it. You don't want to be the loveable moptops any more," Dylan allegedly remarked when The Beatles played him Revolver. The truth is, they never did.

By Rob Chapman
User reviewsSubmit your reviewAverage user rating3 stars2 stars
stewart morroll
west midlands
 
Essential

Pure pop music, these albums sit up there on Pet Sounds, Sgt. pepper aftermath shelf. The difference between the mono and stereo versions at times can be staggering. The last album in the set just shows how many good tracks The Beatles used on albums. Im a loser babys in black no reply and i'll follow the sun only interrupted by mr moonlight.

Sell your dog, pawn the cat if you have to, just go out and buy it. Plus there's a pretty good book as well

Stewart Morroll

Dane Henas
CA
 
What a rip!

Tower Records in Sacramento wants 70 bucks for this
lame cash-in attempt by Capitol. Why would anybody want these versions when the far superior and closer-to-the-artists intended versions are available - namely the British Parlophone releases?

I grew up with these, and I have no nostalgic impulse to own them on CD. I have originals on Capitol LP, and always listen to the original British versions--actually on a Mobile Fidelity LP box set. With the exception of the awkward hard-left/right stereo on the earlier songs,there's nothing really new here (unless of course you want to hear Bernard Purdie's drumming instead of Ringo's!). Even the covers were awful compared to the Parlophone versions.

The ultimate sin came later when they had the audacity to chop songs off of Revolver and Rubber Soul. I wouldn't put it past Capitol to put those out in Vol. 2! I have to admit though, that I would like to see "Yesterday and Today" come out on CD with the original artwork...

Bob Edgar
Ohio
 
Capitol Cashcow

Once again Capitol Records rips off Beatle fans much like they did the first time with the butchered and edited LP's.

This box set is aimed at people desperate to hear updated versions of CD's that EMI is either too stingy or too stupid to release. Just about everyone has remixed and re-mastered their catalogs taking advantage of new technology to modernize and refresh old classics. Interesting that the pioneers in the studio (The Beatles) have only released a trickle of updated material.

Now Capitol steps in to take advantage with this schlock boxset. Save your money, eventually EMI will notice that there's money to be had from Beatle merchandise.

Site design by I-D Media London